NEW YORK – Since the commercialization of transcatheter mitral valve repair, the share of these procedures among all mitral operations has grown exponentially and has also contributed to an increase in the number of overall mitral procedures, including surgical repair, according to an analysis of a national German database reported at the American Association for Thoracic Surgery Mitral Conclave here.
Transcatheter mitral valve repair (TMVR) using the MitraClip device (Abbott Vascular) was first commercialized in Germany in 2008, and in the years since the share of TMVR procedures among all mitral operations increased from 0.3% to 18.1% in 2015 throughout Germany, said Lenard Conradi, MD, surgical director of minimally-invasive and transcatheter heart valve procedures at the University Heart Center Hamburg.
wildpixel/ThinkStock
The goal of the study was to gain insights into how cardiothoracic surgeons in Germany and at Dr. Conradi’s center in particular were approaching TMVR and what types of patients were having the procedure, Dr. Conradi said.
“While the EuroSCORE I of patients we operated on didn’t change at all between these two time frames, there were subtle changes in the patients that we operated on,” he said. “Before the commercialization of TMVR, we tended to have a ratio of organic vs. functional MR [mitral regurgitation] of 50-50; after commercialization of TMVR, many of the functional MR patients were allocated to TMVR.”
Dr. Conradi noted the profile of patients who had mitral valve repair also changed once the transcatheter approach became available. “Ischemic disease with coronary artery disease, previous infarction, or previous cardiac surgery – mostly coronary artery bypass grafting – were much less prevalent in this surgery population after TMVR became available,” he said.
The study also found that 30-day mortality declined from 7% to 4% during the study period. “That was probably due to more adequate patient selection because we had a more appropriate treatment that we could offer these high-risk patients as an alternative to high-risk surgical approaches,” Dr. Conradi said.
The analysis stratified procedure volumes and growth by four age groups: younger than 65 years; 65-74; 75-84; and greater than ore equal to 85. Older patients were more likely to have TMVR. Surgical procedure volumes increased most in the less than 65 group and least in the greater than or equal to 85 group.
In Germany, transcatheter mitral valve procedures are reimbursed at a higher rate than surgical procedures, but that doesn’t fully explain the uptake in TMVR, Dr. Conradi said. “The patients receiving the transcatheter approach vs. surgery still differ fundamentally, but the addition of an interventional program decreases the surgical patient’s mean risk profile and thus optimizes surgical results,” he said. “I think this can only happen if surgeons are closely involved. The indications will broaden for these therapies. There’s no doubt about that.”
Dr. Conradi disclosed receiving travel support and lecture fees from Abbott Vascular.