Expert Commentary

AAP backs zero tolerance for headfirst hits in football


 

AT THE AAP NATIONAL CONFERENCE

References

WASHINGTON – Teaching young athletes to tackle with their heads up and enforcing rules against illegal headfirst hits can reduce the risks of concussions in youth football, according to a new policy statement by the American Academy of Pediatrics.

An emphasis on proper tackling technique and implementing strategies to reduce head hits maintains the integrity of the game while reducing the most serious injuries as well as subconcussive hits, Dr. Gregory L. Landry, Fellow of the American Academy of Pediatrics (FAAP), and professor of pediatrics and orthopedics at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, said in his plenary talk at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Pediatrics.

Dr. Landry, along with Dr. William P. Meehan III, FAAP, led the Council on Sports Medicine and Fitness in writing the AAP’s policy statement on tackling in youth football (Pediatrics 2015 Oct 25. doi: 10.1542/peds.2015-3282).

©David Peeters/iStockphoto.com

In response to growing calls to ban tackling entirely in youth football, and calls to eliminate football from high school sports, the council reviewed the evidence on youth tackling, concussions, and other injuries in football to reach the seven conclusions outlined in the policy statement, Dr. Landry said.

“Most injuries sustained during participation in youth football are minor, including injuries to the head and neck,” according to the policy statement. “The incidences of severe injuries, catastrophic injuries, and concussion, however, are higher in football than most other team sports and appear to increase with age.”

During his talk, Dr. Landry noted that catastrophic injuries occur more frequently in gymnastics and wrestling than in football. Among all youth football injuries, 3.4% are neurologic and 2.5% are fractures. Half are contusions, 16.7% are sprains, and 9.3% are strains.

Within football, young players tend to have far lower rates of concussions, compared to older players. In one 2-year observational study, the overall concussion rates of 7.4 per 1,000 athletic exposures broke down to 4.3 per 1,000 exposures for fourth- and fifth-graders and 14.4 per 1,000 exposures for eighth-graders. On the low end, another study found a concussion rate of 1.8 per 1,000 exposures, with a rate of 0.24 for practices and 6.2 for games.

“One of the common themes is that game rate is always higher than practice rates,” Dr. Landry said. “Running backs seem to be at the highest risk for injuries.”

In addition, tackling is the most common player activity at the time of the injury and at the time of severe injury. “The act of tackling is, in fact, risky business,” Dr. Landry said.

One reason for this relates to improvement in football safety equipment, he explained.

“As football helmets began to improve, football players began leading with their heads instead of their shoulders,” he said. “Leading with the head increases the risk of both concussion and spinal injury. The priority must be that the head must be up when a player tackles someone. The proper way to tackle is leading with the chest.”

A key study showing the effect that heads-up tackling instruction can have on concussion rates involved comparisons with teams taught Heads Up Football, “a comprehensive program developed by USA Football to advance player safety,” according to the program’s website. During the 2014 football season in Indiana, researchers compared teams that participated in the Heads Up program with teams that did not and with a third group of Pop Warner–affiliated teams that had reduced the number of full body contact practices.

Among 71,262 athletic exposures, the rate was lowest for the teams that were both Pop Warner affiliated and Heads Up affiliated, with a rate of 0.97 concussions per 1,000 athletic exposures. The teams involved in neither program had a rate of 7.32 concussions per 1,000 exposures, but even the Heads Up–only teams had a rate more than twice as low, with 2.73 per 1,000 exposures, revealing the importance of not tackling head first, Dr. Landry said.

“That’s the problem with American football – the whole game has changed,” he said, regarding the shift in tackling technique. “And you’re seeing this at the college level and at the professional level.”

In light of the way the game has changed and the risks it presented, the council offered seven conclusions and recommendations in its policy statement:

1. Officials and coaches must enforce the rules of the game, moving toward “zero tolerance of illegal, headfirst hits.” The statement notes a current “culture of tolerance” regarding headfirst tackling. “This culture has to change to one that protects the head for both the tackler and those players being tackled,” the committee stated. “Stronger sanctions for contact to the head, especially of a defenseless player, should be considered, up to and including expulsion from the game.”

Pages

Next Article: