Patients in their 90s with cancer tolerated immunotherapy well with few serious adverse effects, and they lived for an average of 1.6 years after treatment, a small new study within the US Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) health system reports.
Only 6.3% of 48 patients who were treated with immune checkpoint inhibitors experienced the most severe types of side effects – grade III/IV events – and a total of 27% had any adverse effects, according to the report, which was presented at the 2021 annual meeting of the Association of VA Hematology/Oncology (AVAHO) being held virtually and inperson in Denver Colorado, September 24 to September 26, 2021.
“Our project should help give confidence to oncologists treating the elderly,” said Andrew Joseph Benefield, MD, a hematology/oncology fellow at Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center, in an interview. “Immunotherapy can be given safely and likely effectively in select individuals over the age of 90 with good performance status.”
Benefield and colleagues launched their study to gain insight into a little-studied area: How does cancer treatment affects nonagenarians? “I think many oncologists have been in a situation where they encounter an individual over the age of 90 years who has a good performance status, and they've wondered if immunotherapy would be helpful and safe, particularly given our knowledge of waning immune strength as people age,” he said.
The researchers retrospectively tracked patients with cancer who were at least 90 years old from 2016 to 2017 and were treated with immune checkpoint inhibitors. Most were fit or fairly fit with Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) physical performance scales of 0 or 1 (n = 26), and nearly all had cancer in stage IV (n = 42). Melanoma was the most common type of cancer (n = 19), followed by non-small-cell lung cancer (n = 15). Patients were treated with an average of 12.2 cycles.
“In general, we saw that treatment was well-tolerated,” Dr. Benefield said. “We also noted that a trend toward better long-term survival outcomes in individuals with very good performance status at the start of treatment. We hope to parse this out more as we add more data to our data-set, as the numbers are still too small for confident direct comparison.”
Dr. Benefield said he has treated a limited number of patients in their 90s who were highly physical fit for their age and “very eager” to be treated. “They wanted to do anything they could to maintain their lifestyle,” he said. “In my experience, aggressive supportive care and close monitoring for developing toxicities has been most helpful.”
The researchers don’t know the causes of death of many of the patients, and it’s not clear how they fared in their final days. Still, Dr. Benefield said, “extending someone's life by more than 1 year with relatively low risk of adverse effects is reasonable.”
Oncologist Melisa Wong, MD, MAS, of the University of California, San Francisco, reviewed the study and said in an interview that it “a valuable description of outcomes for nonagenarians receiving immunotherapy in the VA healthcare system.” As she noted, “many other studies of immunotherapy among older adults focus on patients aged 65 or 70 and older while very few focus on octogenarians or nonagenarians.”
The findings suggest that “it is important to move beyond chronological age and assess patients’ physiologic age through a geriatric assessment,” she said. “Geriatric assessment-derived risk scores have been shown to predict chemotherapy toxicity for older adults and research to develop similar tools for immunotherapy are ongoing.”
However, she cautioned that older patients may become suffer so much from the most common side effect of immunotherapy -- fatigue – that “their independence is at stake.”
“Some of these patient choose to stop immunotherapy because the side effects aren’t worth it anymore,” she said. “The challenge for oncologists is not knowing in advance which patients will fall into each of these categories.”
She added that her geriatric oncology research focuses on improving risk stratification for older adults, such as those who are at least 70 with lung adenocarcinoma.
Oncologist Grant R. Williams, MD, MSPH, director of the Cancer & Aging Program at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, agreed in an interview that comprehensive geriatric assessments are important to guide treatment in the oldest adults. “In addition, it is important to elicit the goals of treatment as well,” he said. “For older adults that are fit or at least pre-frail and desire aggressive treatment, immunotherapy is a very reasonable approach, particularly when patients are closely monitored for side effects.”
No study funding is reported. The authors report no disclosures. Dr. Wong discloses an immediate family member is an employee and stock holder of Genentech. Dr. Williams has no disclosures.
