Communicating with Families About HPV Vaccines

From the University of Colorado Denver, Aurora, CO.

Abstract

• Objective: To provide evidence-based guidance on strategies that are likely or unlikely to be successful in navigating HPV vaccine conversations with patients and parents.
• Methods: Nonsystematic review of the literature.
• Results: This review highlights some of the most recent innovations in provider HPV vaccine communication and describes provider communication strategies that have been found to improve adolescent vaccination rates in rigorous scientific studies. Promising strategies for which additional research is needed and strategies that probably do not work are also described.
• Conclusion: By understanding what works, what may work, and what not to do when it comes to communicating with families about HPV vaccines, providers can be better prepared for maximizing the impact they can have on adolescent HPV vaccination rates.

Key words: human papillomavirus; vaccine hesitancy; health communication; parents; immunization.

In the United States, more than 14 million people newly acquire genital human papillomavirus (HPV) annually, and 75 million Americans are infected at any given time [1]. As the most common sexually transmitted disease, more than 80% of sexually active U.S. adults are estimated to be infected with HPV by the age of 50 [1,2]. Although the majority of infections are “silent” and resolve without clinical sequelae, a proportion of infected individuals will go on to develop HPV-related diseases. In women, these include cervical cancer and pre-cancer (ie, abnormal Pap smears); cancers of the vagina, vulva, anus, and oropharynx; and genital warts [3]. Males also bear a high burden of HPV-related disease in the form of penile, anal, and oropharyngeal cancers, as well as genital warts [3]. While once thought of as primarily a “woman’s disease” [4], recent research demonstrates men are also significantly impacted by HPV—particularly in the form of oropharyngeal cancers, which are 2 to 3 times more common in men than in women [5]. In fact, it is estimated by the year 2020 more men will die of HPV-related oropharyngeal cancer than women will die of cervical cancer [6,7]. The combined cost of HPV-associated cancers and other conditions is estimated to be $8 billion per year in the United States [8–11].

HPV Vaccines

Effective HPV vaccines have been available for females aged 9 to 26 years since 2006 (bivalent and quadrivalent vaccines) and for males aged 9 to 26 since 2010 (quadrivalent vaccine only) [12]. These vaccines have been shown in clinical trials to be highly efficacious in preventing HPV infection, cervical pre-cancer, and anal, vaginal, penile, and vulvar cancers caused by the HPV types covered in the vaccine [2]. Although their effectiveness against head and neck cancer has not been studied in clinical trials, most experts believe that these vaccines will also provide protection against at least a proportion of these cancers [13,14]. In 2015 the U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved licensure of a 9-valent HPV vaccine that will soon replace the quadrivalent vaccine in the U.S. market [15]. The 9-valent vaccine is licensed for both males and females aged 9 to 26 and is expected to prevent an even higher proportion of HPV-related cancers than earlier HPV vaccines due to the protection against 5 additional oncogenic HPV types [15].