Authors’ Disclosure Statement: The authors report no actual or potential conflict of interest in relation to this article.
Dr. Balog is a Staff Orthopedic Surgeon, Tripler Army Medical Center, Honolulu, Hawaii. Mr. Blanks is a Staff Physician Assistant, OrthoGeorgia, Macon, Georgia. Dr. Dykstra is a Staff Orthopedic Surgeon, Black Hills Orthopedic and Spine Center, Rapid City, South Dakota. Dr. Parada is Staff Orthopedic Surgeon, Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Fort Gordon, Georgia. Dr. Arrington is a Staff Orthopedic Surgeon and Director, Orthopedic Surgery Residency Program, Madigan Army Medical Center, Tacoma, Washington.
Address correspondence to: LTC Todd P. Balog, MD, 1 Jarrett White Rd, Honolulu, HI 96859 (tel, 832-326-5583; email, tbalog99@gmail.com).
MAJ Todd P. Balog, MD MAJ Benjamin P. Blanks, PA MAJ Aaron D. Dykstra, MD MAJ Stephen A. Parada, MD COL (ret) Edward D. Arrington, MD . Epidemiology of Existing Extensor Mechanism Pathology in Primary Anterior Cruciate Ligament Ruptures in an Active-Duty Population. Am J Orthop.
August 31, 2018
References
The goal of this study is to obtain epidemiological evidence of the prevalence of existing extensor mechanism pathologies in patients with acute ACL ruptures and determine how these pathologies may relate to the choice of graft. Out of 197 patients studied, over 10% presented with radiographic evidence of pathologies that could influence the choice of graft. This prevalence is certainly significant enough for surgeons to consider including a radiographic evaluation of the extensor mechanism in their standard ACL rupture work-up.
This study presents obvious limitations. While we report the prevalence of some extensor mechanism pathologies, no definitive evidence that recommends against the use of these autografts from these affected individuals has yet been published. In addition, our diagnosis of patella tendinopathy is based solely on MRI findings with no information regarding clinical symptoms. This limitation is a weakness as several additional studies have questioned the validity of a 7 mm proximal patella tendon thickness.23,24 Furthermore, no studies demonstrating the inferior strength of autografts with the co-existing findings described in our work have yet been performed.
CONCLUSION
We found that 10% of active-duty patients presenting for ACL reconstruction demonstrated radiographic evidence of an extensor mechanism pathology that could affect the harvesting of or integrity of select autografts. Given the recent trend of functionally equivocal results in ACL reconstructions utilizing a variety of grafts, this information could and should influence surgical recommendations for graft utilization to obtain optimal surgical results.
