Slow the process down, give appropriate psychotherapy
Stella O’Malley is a psychotherapist who works with transitioners and detransitioners and is a founding member of the International Association of Therapists for Desisters and Detransitioners (IATDD).
Whatever the outcome of the appeal process, Ms. O’Malley said she would like to see the Tavistock slow down and take a broader approach to counseling children before referral to endocrinology services.
In discussing therapy prior to transition, Ms. O’Malley stated that her clients often say they did not explore their inner motivations or other possible reasons for their distress, and the therapy was focused more on when they transition, rather than being sure it was something they wanted to do.
“We need to learn from the mistakes made with people like Keira Bell. , especially when [children are] ... young and especially when they’re traumatized,” Ms. O’Malley said.
“Had they received a more conventional therapy, they might have thought about their decision from different perspectives and in the process acquired more self-awareness, which would have been more beneficial.”
“The ‘affirmative’ approach to gender therapy is too narrow; we need to look at the whole individual. Therapy in other areas would never disregard other, nongender issues such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or anxiety [which often co-exist with gender dysphoria] – issues bleed into each other,” Ms. O’Malley pointed out. “We need a more exploratory approach.”
“I’d also like to see other therapists all over the [U.K.] who are perfectly qualified and capable of working with gender actually start working with gender issues,” she said, noting that such an approach might also help reduce the long waiting list at the Tavistock.
The latter had been overwhelmed, and this led to a speeding up of the assessment process, which led to a number of professionals resigning from the service in recent years, saying children were being “fast-tracked” to medical transition.
Fertility and sexual function are complex issues for kids
Also asked to comment was Claire Graham, from Genspect, a group that describes itself as a voice for parents of gender-questioning kids.
She told this news organization that “parents are rightly concerned about their children’s ability to consent to treatments that may lead to infertility and issues surrounding sexual function.” She added that other countries in Europe were changing their approach. “Look to Sweden and Finland, who have both rowed back on puberty blockers and no longer recommend them.”
Ms. Graham, who has worked with children with differences in sexual development, added that it was very difficult for children and young people to understand the life-long implications of decisions made at an early age.
“How can children understand what it is to live with impaired sexual functioning if they have never had sex? Likewise, fertility is a complex issue. Most people do not want to become parents as teenagers, but we understand that this will often change as they grow,” said Ms. Graham.
“Many parents worry that their child is not being considered in the whole [and] that their child’s ability to consent to medical interventions for gender dysphoria is impacted by comorbidities, such as a diagnosis of autism or a history of mental health issues. These children are particularly vulnerable.”
“At Genspect, we hope that the decision from the ... court is upheld,” Ms. Graham concluded.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.