Outrage over the high cost of cancer care has focused on skyrocketing drug prices, including the $475,000 price tag for the country’s first gene therapy, Novartis’ Kymriah (tisagenlecleucel), a leukemia treatment approved in August.
But the total costs of tisagenlecleucel and the 21 similar drugs in development – known as CAR T-cell therapies – will be far higher than many have imagined, reaching $1 million or more per patient, according to leading cancer experts. The next CAR T-cell drug could be approved as soon as November.
Although Kymriah’s price tag has “shattered oncology drug pricing norms,” said Leonard Saltz, MD, chief of gastrointestinal oncology at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York, “the sticker price is just the starting point.”
These therapies lead to a cascade of costs, propelled by serious side effects that require sophisticated management, Dr. Saltz said. For this class of drugs, Dr, Saltz advised consumers to “think of the $475,000 as parts, not labor.”
Hagop Kantarjian, MD, leukemia specialist and professor at the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, estimates tisagenlecleucel’s total cost could reach $1.5 million.
CAR T-cell therapy is expensive because of the unique way that it works. Doctors harvest patients’ immune cells, genetically alter them to rev up their ability to fight cancer, then reinfuse them into patients.
Taking the brakes off the immune system, Dr. Kantarjian said, can lead to life-threatening complications that require lengthy hospitalizations and expensive medications, which are prescribed in addition to conventional cancer therapy, rather than in place of it.
Keith D. Eaton, MD, a Seattle oncologist, said he ran up medical bills of $500,000 when he participated in a clinical trial of CAR T cells in 2013, even though all patients in the study received the medication for free. Dr. Eaton, who was diagnosed with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), spent nearly 2 months in the hospital.
Like Dr. Eaton, nearly half of patients who receive CAR T cells develop cytokine storm. Other serious side effects include strokelike symptoms and coma.
The cytokine storm felt like “the worst flu of your life,” said Dr. Eaton, now aged 51 years. His fever spiked so high that a hospital nurse assumed the thermometer was broken. Dr. Eaton replied, “It’s not broken. My temperature is too high to register on the thermometer.”
Although Dr. Eaton recovered, he wasn’t done with treatment. His doctors recommended a bone marrow transplant, another harrowing procedure, at a cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Dr. Eaton said he feels fortunate to be healthy today, with tests showing no evidence of leukemia. His insurer paid for almost everything.
Kymriah’s sticker price is especially “outrageous” given its relatively low manufacturing costs, said Walid F. Gellad, MD, codirector of the Center for Pharmaceutical Policy and Prescribing at the University of Pittsburgh.
The gene therapy process used to create tisagenlecleucel costs about $15,000, according to a 2012 presentation by Carl H. June, MD, who pioneered CAR T-cell research at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. Dr. June could not be reached for comment.
To quell unrest about price, Novartis has offered patients and insurers a new twist on the money-back guarantee.
Novartis will charge for the drug only if patients go into remission within 1 month of treatment. In a key clinical trial, 83% of the children and young adults treated with tisagenlecleucel went into remission within 3 months. Novartis calls the plan “outcomes-based pricing.”
Novartis is “working through the specific details” of how the pricing plan will affect the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, which pays for care for many cancer patients, company spokesperson Julie Masow said. “There are many hurdles” to this type of pricing plan but, Ms. Masow said, “Novartis is committed to making this happen.”
She also said that Kymriah’s manufacturing costs are much higher than $15,000, although she didn’t cite a specific dollar amount. She noted that Novartis has invested heavily in the technology, designing “an innovative manufacturing facility and process specifically for cellular therapies.”
As for Kymriah-related hospital and medication charges, “costs will vary from patient to patient and treatment center to treatment center, based on the level of care each patient requires,” Ms. Masow said. “Kymriah is a one-time treatment that has shown remarkable early, deep, and durable responses in these children who are very sick and often out of options.”
Some doctors said tisagenlecleucel, which could be used by about 600 patients a year, offers an incalculable benefit for desperately ill young people. The drug is approved for children and young adults with B-cell ALL who already have been treated with at least two other cancer therapies.
“A kid’s life is priceless,” said Michelle Hermiston, MD, director of pediatric immunotherapy at Benioff Children’s Hospital, at the University of California, San Francisco. “Any given kid has the potential to make financial impacts over a lifetime that far outweigh the cost of their cure. From this perspective, every child in my mind deserves the best curative therapy we can offer.”
Other cancer doctors say the Novartis plan is no bargain.
About 36% of patients who go into remission with tisagenlecleucel relapse within 1 year, said Vinay Prasad, MD, of Oregon Health & Science University, Portland. Many of these patients will need additional treatment, said Dr. Prasad, who wrote an editorial about tisagenlecleucel’s price Oct. 4 in Nature.
“If you’ve paid half a million dollars for drugs and half a million dollars for care, and a year later your cancer is back, is that a good deal?” asked Dr. Saltz, who cowrote a recent editorial on tisagenlecleucel’s price in JAMA.
Steve Miller, MD, chief medical officer for Express Scripts, said it would be more fair to judge Kymriah’s success after 6 months of treatment, rather than 1 month. Dr. Prasad goes even further. He said Novartis should issue refunds for any patient who relapses within 3 years.
A consumer-advocate group called Patients for Affordable Drugs also has said that tisagenlecleucel costs too much, given that the federal government spent more than $200 million over 2 decades to support the basic research into CAR T-cell therapy, long before Novartis bought the rights.
Rep. Lloyd Doggett (D-Texas) wrote a letter to the Medicare program’s director last month asking for details on how the Novartis payment deal will work.
“As Big Pharma continues to put price gouging before patient access, companies will point more and more proudly at their pricing agreements,” Rep. Doggett wrote. “But taxpayers deserve to know more about how these agreements will work – whether they will actually save the government money, defray these massive costs, and ensure that they can access lifesaving medications.”
KHN’s coverage related to aging & improving care of older adults is supported by The John A. Hartford Foundation. Kaiser Health News is a national health policy news service that is part of the nonpartisan Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation.