ASCO addresses financial barriers to cancer clinical trials

^{Photo by Esther Dyson}

Preparing drug for a trial

The American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) has issued a policy statement addressing financial barriers to patient participation in cancer clinical trials.

ASCO’s policy statement outlines a series of recommendations designed to address multiple financial barriers that impede access to clinical trials, including patient costs that aren’t covered consistently by health insurance; a lack of information provided to patients about clinical trial costs; and limited available research data on financial hardships related to participation in clinical trials.

“Clinical trials are essential for evaluating the safety and efficacy of new cancer treatments, but cancer researchers have seen consistently low patient participation levels—especially among underserved patient populations—in part, due to the financial burdens facing many patients with cancer,” said ASCO President Monica M. Bertagnolli, MD.

“Addressing financial barriers will help improve the enrollment rate and the efficiency, quality, and applicability of cancer research. By including more—and more diverse—participants in our research studies, we expand our ability to care for all patients.”

The recommendations in ASCO’s policy statement include:

1. Improve payer clinical trial coverage policies. Payment policies should be revised to be made consistent, streamlined, and transparent to all stakeholders.
   1. Payers should have clear definitions of “routine costs.”
   2. Payers should streamline prior authorization processes and facilitate trial enrollment through provider reimbursement of clinical trial-related services.
   3. State Medicaid programs should universally guarantee coverage of routine care costs of clinical trials for their beneficiaries.
   4. The U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) should revise current policy that requires Medicare Advantage beneficiaries to revert to fee-for-service coverage during clinical trials.
   5. CMS’s Innovation Center should explore the effectiveness of alternative payment models in support of clinical trial accrual.

2. During the clinical trials development and enrollment process, provide patients with clear, transparent information about potential trial-related out-of-pocket costs and include mechanisms to support patient financial/health literacy.
   1. Clinical trial sponsors should perform—and make available to enrolling institutions—comprehensive, prospective coverage analyses.
   2. Research sites should consider offering in-house financial navigation/counseling to patients or consider partnering with organizations that provide such services.
   3. Design clinical trials to minimize incremental costs, consistent with scientific objectives and participant safety.

3. Remove impediments to ethically appropriate financial compensation for trial-related out-of-pocket costs. Provision of such financial support should not be considered undue inducement.
   1. Office for Human Research Protections should develop guidance on targeted financial support.

4. Incentivize research that will better characterize patient costs incurred for participating in cancer clinical trials and support the longer-term development of tools to identify and mitigate the risk of trial-associated financial hardship.

“Continued progress against cancer depends on improving patient access to participation in clinical research,” Dr. Bertagnolli said.

“The recommendations in ASCO’s statement aim to ensure that no patient is denied access to a clinical trial for financial reasons and that patients are not harmed financially because of their contributions to advancing science. Ultimately, this is about strengthening the nation’s cancer research enterprise as a whole.”