Commentary
Noninvasive ventilation offers an alternative to invasive mechanical ventilation for providing ventilatory support for respiratory failure, and may offer benefits as it could avert adverse effects associated with invasive mechanical ventilation, particularly in the management of respiratory failure due to congestive heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.1 There is evidence for potential benefits of use of noninvasive ventilation in other clinical scenarios, such as pneumonia in older adults with comorbidities, though its clinical utility is not as well established for other diseases.2
As noninvasive ventilation is introduced into clinical practice, it is not surprising that over the period of the study (2000 to 2017) that its use increased substantially. Advance directives that involve discussion of life-sustaining treatments, including in scenarios with respiratory failure, may also result in physician orders that specify whether an individual desires invasive mechanical ventilation versus other medical treatments, including noninvasive ventilation.3,4 By examining the temporal trends of use of noninvasive and invasive ventilation, this study reveals that invasive mechanical ventilation use among decedents with dementia and cancer has increased, despite increases in the use of noninvasive ventilation. It is important to understand further what would explain these temporal trends and whether the use of noninvasive and also invasive mechanical ventilation at the end of life represents appropriate care with clear goals or whether it may represent overuse. It is also less clear in the end-of-life care scenario what the goals of treatment with noninvasive ventilation would be, especially if it does not avert the use of invasive mechanical ventilation.
The study includes decedents only, thus limiting the ability to draw conclusions about clinically appropriate care.5 Further studies should examine a cohort of patients who have serious and life-threatening illness to examine the trends and potential effects of noninvasive ventilation on outcomes and utilization, as individuals who have improved and survived would not be included in this present decedent cohort.
Applications for Clinical Practice
This study highlights changes in the use of noninvasive and invasive ventilation over time and the different trends seen among subgroups with different diagnoses. For older adults with serious comorbid illness such as dementia, it is especially important to have discussions on advance directives so that care at the end of life is concordant with the patient’s wishes and that unnecessary, burdensome care can be averted. Further studies to understand and define the appropriate use of noninvasive and invasive mechanical ventilation for older adults with significant comorbidities who have serious, life-threatening illness are needed to ensure appropriate clinical treatment at the end of life.
–William W. Hung, MD, MPH