Florida’s Miami-Dade County reportedly has the largest percentage of residents with serious mental illnesses (SMI) among large U.S. communities. And a Florida judge who helped develop approaches aimed at sparing his state’s residents with mental illness from harmful, avoidable, and expensive bouts of prison time wants to see his strategies replicated.
Courtesy Judge Steve Leifman
Judge Steve Leifman
“There is something terribly wrong with a society that is willing to spend more money to incarcerate people who are ill than to treat them,” Judge Steve Leifman of the 11th judicial circuit court said at a National Institute of Mental Health conference on mental health services research.
Judge Leifman in 2000 created the Criminal Mental Health Project. It’s been recognized for its success in keeping people with SMI from becoming ensnared in the criminal justice system because of minor offenses. It also helps those who do spend time in jail from returning.
In Miami-Dade County, for example, 97 people were a significant driver of costs in the criminal justice system in a study that was completed in 2010, Judge Leifman said. The members of this group were largely men who suffered from schizophrenia spectrum disorders and were homeless with a co-occurring disorder. Combined, the number of arrests for this group was about 2,200 over a 5-year period, Judge Leifman said. They spent 27,000 days in the Miami-Dade County jail – costing taxpayers about $13.7 million.
Judge Leifman said. “They would have had a shot at an education. They would have had housing. They probably would have done a lot better.”
Through the Criminal Mental Health Project, Judge Leifman and his colleagues seek to both prevent people with mental illness from being arrested and jailed for minor offenses, and to provide a support network for those who have reached jail. The project’s “prebooking diversion” efforts are built on a model developed in Memphis, Tenn., in the late 1980s. Through it, police officers get special training in recognizing mental illness and resolving crises in which people who have these disorders are involved.
The project’s “postbooking diversion” techniques require participants to voluntarily consent to mental health treatment and services. The program is open only to those less serious felonies, which can include drug charges and theft. Through participation in the Criminal Mental Health Project, people can have charges dismissed or reduced. The program provides them with connections to community-based treatment, support, and housing services, according to its website.
Participants in the program who were charged with minor felonies had 75% fewer jail bookings and jail days after enrolling in the Criminal Mental Health Project (N Engl J Med. 2016;374:1701-3).
Judge Leifman said the postbooking jail diversion program has, since 2001, served more than 4,000 individuals. Recidivism rates among participants charged with misdemeanors dropped from roughly 75% to 20%, he said.
Still, Judge Leifman describes his role as a judge as making him a “gatekeeper to the largest psychiatric facility in Florida – the Miami-Dade County Jail.” The jail houses about 1,200 people with serious mental illness on any given day, according to the Criminal Mental Health Project’s website.
Judge Leifman said that, ultimately, he wants more communities to devote more resources to providing medical care for people with mental illness.