A teen with seizures, amnesia, and troubled family dynamics

Because of gradual improvement in Ms. A’s symptoms and no imminent safety concerns, she is discharged home with valproic acid, 1,000 mg/d, and oxcarbazepine, 1,200 mg/d, and follow-up appointments with her primary care physician, a neurologist, and a psychiatrist.

The authors’ observations
Dissociative amnesia
Generalized dissociative amnesia is dif­ficult to differentiate from factitious disorder or malingering. According to DSM-5, there is loss of episodic memory in dissociative amnesia, in which the person is unable to recall the stressful event after trauma (Table 1).¹ Although there have been case reports of dissocia­tive amnesia with loss of semantic and procedural memory, episodic memory is the last to return.² In Ms. A’s case, there was no immediate basis to explain amne­sia onset, although she had experienced the trauma of losing her sister. She had episodic and mostly semantic memory loss.

Although organic causes can pre­cipitate amnesia,³ Ms. A’s EEG and MRI results did not reflect that. Patients with a dissociative disorder often report some physical, sexual, or emotional abuse.⁴ Although Ms. A did not report any abuse, it cannot be completely ruled out because of her sister’s history of abuse.

Suicidality or self-injurious behavior is common among adults with dissociative amnesia, although it is not well studied in children.^4,5 Generally, the constella­tion of primary dissociative symptoms that patients develop are forgetfulness, fragmentation, and emotional numbing. Ms. A presented with some of these fea­tures; did she, in fact, have dissociative amnesia?

Factitious amnesia
Factious amnesia (Table 2)⁶ is a symptom of factious disorder in which amnesia appears with the motivation to assume a sick role.³ Ms. A’s amnesia garnered sig­nificant attention from her mother and other family members; this may have been related to insecurity in her family relationships because her sister was given up to the state. She also could be afraid of entering adolescence and leaving her sister behind. Did she want more time to bond with her mother? Did she experi­ence emotional benefit from being cared for by medical professionals?⁷ Her affect during interviews was blunted and her attitude was nonchalant, and her multiple visits to the hospital since childhood for abdominal pain, abscesses (it isn’t clear whether the abscesses were related to self-injury and scratching), tics, seizures, and, recently, amnesia and hallucinations indi­cated some desire to occupy a sick role. Furthermore, the severity of her symp­toms seemed to be increasing over time, from somatic to neurologic (seizure-like episodes) to significant and less frequent psychiatric symptoms (amnesia and hal­lucinations). One could speculate that her symptoms were escalating because she was not receiving the attention she needed.

Malingered amnesia
Although malingering is not a psychi­atric diagnosis, it can be a focus of clini­cal attention. It is challenging to identify malingered cognitive impairments.⁸ Children often have difficulty malinger­ing symptoms because they have limited understanding of the illness they are try­ing to simulate.⁹ Many malingerers do not want to participate in their medical work up and might exhibit a hostile attitude toward examiners (Table 2⁶). Clinicians could rely on family to provide informa­tion regarding history and inconsistencies in clinical deficits.⁹ The clinical interview, mental status examination, and collateral information are crucial for identifying malingering.

Most of Ms. A’s seizure-like episodes happened in specific contexts, such as in school, but not at friends’ houses, raising the question of whether she is aware of her episodes. Ms. A’s grades are consis­tently good; because she is being home schooled, there is no secondary gain from not going to school. There is no other reason to speculate that she was malingering.

The inconsistency of Ms. A’s symptoms and her compliance with assessment and treatment did not reflect malingering. Interestingly, Ms. A’s amnesia was retrograde in nature. There have been more studies on malingered anterograde amne­sia⁸ than on retrograde amnesia, making her presentation even more unusual.

Amnesia presenting as conversion disorder
Amnesia as a symptom of conversion disorder is referred as psychogenic amne­sia; the memory loss mostly is isolated retrograde amnesia.¹⁰ Ms. A likely had unconsciously produced symptoms of non-epileptic seizures, followed by audi­tory and visual hallucinations not related to her seizures, and then later developed selective transient amnesia. Conversion disorder seemed to be the diagnosis most consistent with her indifference (“la belle indifference”) and the significant atten­tion she gained from the acute memory loss (Table 3).¹ It seemed that she devel­oped multiple symptoms in progression leading toward a conversion disorder diagnosis. The question arises whether Ms. A’s presentation is a gradually increasing cry for help or reflects depres­sive or anxiety symptoms, which often are comorbid with conversion disorder.

FOLLOW-UP Suicide attempt
Ms. A has frequent visits to the ED with symp­toms of syncope and seizures and undergoes medical work-up and multiple EEGs. A pro­longed 5-day video EEG is performed to assess seizure episodes after AEDs were withdrawn, but no seizure activity is elicited. She also has an ED visit for recurrent tic emergence.