Applied Evidence

Personality disorders: A measured response

Author and Disclosure Information

Improving your understanding of these disorders will help you identify specific diagnoses, ensure appropriate treatment, and reduce frustration during office visits.


 

References

PRACTICE RECOMMENDATIONS

› Maintain a high index of suspicion for personality disorders (PDs) in patients who appear to be “difficult,” and take care to distinguish these diagnoses from primary mood, anxiety, and psychotic disorders. C
› Refer patients with PDs for psychotherapy, as it is considered the mainstay of treatment—particularly for borderline PD. B
› Use pharmacotherapy judiciously as an adjunctive treatment for PD. B

Strength of recommendation (SOR)

A Good-quality patient-oriented evidence
B
Inconsistent or limited-quality patient-oriented evidence
C
Consensus, usual practice, opinion, disease-oriented evidence, case series

Personality disorders (PDs) are common, affecting up to 15% of US adults, and are associated with comorbid medical and psychiatric conditions and increased utilization of health care resources.1,2 Having a basic understanding of these patterns of thinking and behaving can help family physicians (FPs) identify specific PD diagnoses, ensure appropriate treatment, and reduce the frustration that arises when an individual is viewed as a “difficult patient.”

Here we describe the diagnostic features of the disorders in the 3 major clusters of PDs and review an effective approach to the management of the most common disorder in each cluster, using a case study patient.

Defense mechanisms offer clues that your patient may have a PD

Personality is an enduring pattern of inner experience and behaviors that is relatively stable across time and in different situations. Such traits comprise an individual’s inherent makeup.1 PDs are diagnosed when an individual’s personality traits create significant distress or impairment in daily functioning. Specifically, PDs have a negative impact on cognition, affect, interpersonal relationships, and/or impulse control.1

One of the ways people alleviate distress is by using defense mechanisms. Defense mechanisms are unconscious mental processes that individuals use to resolve conflicts, and thereby reduce anxiety and depression on a conscious level. Taken alone, defense mechanisms are not pathologic, but they may become maladaptive in certain stressful circumstances, such as when receiving medical treatment. Recognizing patterns of chronic use of certain defense mechanisms may be a clue that your patient has a PD. TABLE 13,4 and TABLE 23,4 provide an overview of common defense mechanisms used by patients with PDs.

The American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th edition (DSM-5) organizes PDs into 3 clusters based on similar and often overlapping symptoms.1TABLE 31 provides a brief summary of the characteristic features of each disorder in these clusters.

Cluster A: Odd, eccentric

Patients with one of these disorders are odd, eccentric, or bizarre in their behavior and thinking. There appears to be a genetic link between cluster A PDs (especially schizotypal) and schizophrenia.5 These patients rarely seek treatment for their disorder because they have limited insight into their maladaptive traits.5,6

CASE 1 › Daniel A, age 57, has hypertension and hyperlipidemia and comes in to see his FP for a 6-month follow-up appointment. He never misses appointments, but has a history of poor adherence with prescribed medications. He enjoys his discussions with you in the office, although he often perseverates on conspiracy theories. He lives alone and has never been married. He believes that some of the previously prescribed medications, including a statin and a thiazide diuretic, were interfering with the absorption of “positive nutrients” in his diet. He also refuses to take the generic form of a statin, which he believes was adulterated by the government to be sold at lower cost.

Mr. A demonstrates the odd and eccentric beliefs that characterize schizotypal personality disorder. How can his FP best help him adhere to his medication regimen? (For the answer, click here.)

Schizotypal personality disorder shares certain disturbances of thought with schizophrenia, and is believed to exist on a spectrum with other primary psychotic disorders. Support for this theory comes from the higher rates of schizotypal PD among family members of patients with schizophrenia. There is a genetic component to the disorder.3,5,6

Clinically, these patients appear odd and eccentric with unusual beliefs. They may have a fascination with magic, clairvoyance, telepathy, or other such notions.1,5 Although the perceptual disturbances are unusual and often bizarre, they are not frank delusions: patients with schizotypal PD are willing to consider alternative explanations for their beliefs and can engage in rational discussion. Cognitive deficits, particularly of memory and attention, are common and distressing to patients. Frequently, the presenting complaint is depression and anxiety due to the emotional discord and isolation from others.1,3,5,6

Continue to cluster B >>

Pages

Next Article:

Axis I psychiatric disorders high in skin-restricted lupus patients

Related Articles