Weighing other factors
If he could apply again, Dr. Fathy said he has the experience to know he wouldn’t have put as much weight in the U.S. News rankings. “At the time I was applying, it was hard to understand exactly what the rankings stood for,” he said. “I thought maybe a higher ranking meant better research opportunities and better connections. It’s hard to let go of the prestige relative to it all.”
His final two options had been Penn or Stanford. “Penn was the better choice for me, not because of its rankings, but because I had unique mentors and research opportunities there, and also because I had a scholarship,” he said. “I also had no family on the West Coast, which would have made a difference had I chosen Stanford.”
Dr. Fathy is happy the rankings have lost some of their prestige.
“I’m hoping that as schools pull out, it will demonstrate to applicants that the rankings aren’t where they should focus,” he said. “I also hope that down the line, it will prevent the name of a school from being such a big factor in residency applications.”
Dr. Fathy added that applying to residency programs has been an inequitable process, as institutions seem to judge applicants based on where they went to medical school. “When you look at the match lists, I believe programs put preference on students coming out of higher-ranking institutions,” he said.
Ahmed Mukhtar Ahmed, MPP, MSc, who will graduate soon from Harvard Medical School, said he hopes that the withdrawals from the ranking system will benefit future students. His initial choice of Harvard wasn’t the result of the rankings, he said. His family came from Somalia in 1996. “My mom sacrificed so much for me to get where I am, and when I was choosing a school, Harvard was the only name she recognized. It meant so much for her that I was accepted here.”
Beyond the emotional tie-in, however, Mr. Ahmed found Harvard to be the right fit for other reasons. “There’s so much opportunity here for someone with a focus on public health, and it has served me well.”
Still, Mr. Ahmed was not ignorant of the rankings. “I don’t know too many students who didn’t have their fingers on the pulse of the rankings,” he said. “There’s awareness that it’s not a good metric, but when applying to residencies, they keep in mind where you went to med school. So, we all have it in the back of our minds, for better or worse.”
Like Dr. Fathy, Mr. Ahmed can see the cracks in the ranking system. “I think the exodus from the rankings is good for applicants and also for the landscape of institutions, in general,” he said. “There’s nothing that says the number-one school is the best school for you.”
Mr. Ahmed points to other criteria, including financing opportunities, when judging a prospective school. “Talk to students and ask about how responsive administration is should a concern pop up,” he said. “Are they invested in student well-being? Also look at the diversity of institutions and experiences you will have. That’s something I didn’t appreciate until I was a student. I learned new things from the different hospitals I rotated through.”